[Review] Captain Beefheart and His Magic Band: Safe As Milk (1967)

What do you get when you mix a poet, an artist, a talented band of blues-rock crazies and drugs? Clue: it ain’t milk.

Kronomyth 1.0: The fallow land, the untilled farm produces only milkweed at best.

The yellow brick road of rock and roll, it turns out, leads to a madman’s shack in the Mojave desert strung with barbed wire and faded shrines to lost gods. That’s the sense you have listening to Safe As Milk today: that you shouldn’t be here and yet every step has led you to this unlikely crossroads of music, madness and more than a little marijuana.

The polite thing to do, it seems, is not to stare at the human trainwreck that is Don Van Vliet and instead point out that the music is far ahead of its time or, more accurately, far out of its time. Van Vliet has the (beef)heart and eye of an artist, tainted with the craziness that plagues many great artists. He is apparently a difficult person to work with, and you get the sense listening to these songs that not one of them was easily birthed, but that each was breached in the brainbox of Beefheart and could only be cajoled out with liberal amounts of unctuous patience from Ry Cooder and the rest of the band. For their efforts, a freakish litter featuring the likes of “Abba Zabba,” “Electricity,” “Zig Zag Wanderer,” “Dropout Boogie” and the surprisingly sweet “I’m Glad” was spawned. The lyrics, written by Herb Bermann, are poems placed in Beefheart’s improbable marble mouth and spit out like THC-enriched tobacco juice (which is probably an accurate description of Van Vliet’s saliva at the time).

Once heard, Safe As Milk isn’t soon forgotten. Reference points in 1967 for this music were hard to come by; a reverent (versus irreverent) Frank Zappa, maybe, or a postmodern deconstruction of Howlin’ Wolf or Screamin’ Jay Hawkins. I would tell you that Safe As Milk is a work of genius, though I don’t believe Beefheart to be the sole source of that genius, but rather a catalyst for it, as the man is more of a musical force than a musician. Maybe that’s the best way to describe this album: a force of a musical nature.

Read more Captain Beefheart reviews

Original LP Version

A1. Sure ‘Nuff ‘N Yes I Do (Don Van Vliet/Herb Bermann) (2:10)
A2. Zig Zag Wanderer (Don Van Vliet/Herb Bermann) (2:35)
A3. Call On Me (Don Van Vliet) (3:10)
A4. Dropout Boogie (Don Van Vliet/Herb Bermann) (2:20)
A5. I’m Glad (Don Van Vliet) (3:22)
A6. Electricity (Don Van Vliet/Herb Bermann) (3:00)
B1. Yellow Brick Road (Don Van Vliet/Herb Bermann) (2:50)
B2. Abba Zabba (Don Van Vliet) (3:55)
B3. Plastic Factory (Don Van Vliet/Herb Bermann/Jerry Handley) (3:00)
B4. Where There’s Woman (Don Van Vliet/Herb Bermann) (2:05)
B5. Grown So Ugly (Robert Pete Williams) (2:22)
B6. Autumn’s Child (Don Van Vliet/Herb Bermann) (4:35)

Reissue bonus tracks
13. Safe As Milk (Take 5)
14. On Tomorrow
15. Big Black Baby Shoes
16. Flower Pot
17. Dirty Blue Gene
18. Trust Us (Take 9)
19. Korn Ring Finger

The Players

Ry Cooder (guitar, bass, slide guitar, percussion), John French (drums, backing vocals, percussion), Jerry Handley (bass, backing vocals), Alex St. Clair Snouffer (guitar, backing vocals, bass, percussion), Don Van Vliet (lead vocals, harmonica, marimba) with Samuel Hoffman (theremin on A6/B6), Milt Holland (log drum, tambourine, percussion), Taj Mahal (tambourine, percussion), Russ Titelman (guitar). Produced by Bob Krasnow and Richard Perry; engineered by Hank Cicalo.

The Pictures

Photography by Guy Webster. Graphics by Tom Wilkes.

The Plastic

Released on stereo elpee in June 1967 in the US (Buddah, BDS 5001).

  1. Re-issued on elpee in 1970 in the US (Buddah, BDS 5063).
  2. Re-packaged as Gold Rock on elpee in 1976 in Germany (Buddah, 201.719) with different cover.
  3. Re-released on expanded compact disc in 1999 in the US (SBME Special Markets) with 7 bonus tracks.
  4. Re-released on expanded 180g vinyl 2LP in 2011 in the Netherlands (Music On Vinyl) with 7 bonus tracks.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *